{ "checkpoint": "RMO84", "event_date": "2010-06-13", "status": "CONDITIONAL_EMISSION_MODEL_TENSION", "observer_sentence": "The checked MHD model remains available, but this simple emission model does not match both EUV delays and the radio density at the five tested temperatures.", "is_new_solar_family_classification": false, "does_not_rule_out_shock": true, "source_sha256": "4fd1c0062e05ee93f0bda015b1ef13bf73ebdfd82a6dea9e85f4e8e8a235798d", "observed_time_bounds_s": { "211": [ { "exact_fraction": "88", "value": 88.0 }, { "exact_fraction": "112", "value": 112.0 } ], "335": [ { "exact_fraction": "263", "value": 263.0 }, { "exact_fraction": "287", "value": 287.0 } ] }, "time_ratio_bounds": [ { "exact_fraction": "263/112", "value": 2.3482142857142856 }, { "exact_fraction": "287/88", "value": 3.2613636363636362 } ], "joint_radio_density_bounds_cm3": [ { "exact_fraction": "14062500000000/201601", "value": 69754118.28314343 }, { "exact_fraction": "20250000000000/201601", "value": 100445930.32772654 } ], "joint_radio_density_central_cm3": { "exact_fraction": "17015625000000/201601", "value": 84402483.12260357 }, "radio_identity": "n2 = n1 * X = (fL/(2 K))^2 * (fU/fL)^2 = (fU/(2 K))^2", "rows": [ { "temperature_MK": "2.4", "coefficients_s_per_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "325703915000000000000000/49503732804609", "value": 6579380918.314823 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "28729956194164150140185000000000000000/1237792337818262451501357801", "value": 23210643107.392056 } }, "ratio": { "exact_fraction": "5745991238832830028037/1628781457655554290887", "value": 3.527785272742195 }, "required_density_cm3": { "211": [ { "exact_fraction": "20356494687500000000000/346526129632263", "value": 58744472.484953776 }, { "exact_fraction": "40712989375000000000000/544541060850699", "value": 74765692.25357753 } ], "335": [ { "exact_fraction": "28729956194164150140185000000000000000/355246400953841323580889688887", "value": 80873320.93167964 }, { "exact_fraction": "28729956194164150140185000000000000000/325539384846203024744857101663", "value": 88253395.84559716 } ] }, "joint_EUV_density_cm3": null, "joint_EUV_radio_density_cm3": null, "predicted_times_s": { "stated_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "162851957500000000/2326675441816623", "value": 69.99341402462578 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "14364978097082075070092500000000/58176239877458335220563816647", "value": 246.92173518502184 } }, "arithmetic_product_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "407129893750000000/5791936738139253", "value": 70.29253117857716 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "35912445242705187675231250000000/144821703524736706825658862717", "value": 247.97695627555612 } }, "upstream_reference_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "16285195750000000/148511198413827", "value": 109.65634863858038 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "1436497809708207507009250000000/3713377013454787354504073403", "value": 386.8440517898676 } } }, "printed_times_s": { "211": 110, "335": 386 }, "density_implied_by_printed_times_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "32570391500000000000000/544541060850699", "value": 59812553.802862026 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "14364978097082075070092500000000000000/238893921198924653139762055593", "value": 60131199.76008304 } } }, { "temperature_MK": "2.6", "coefficients_s_per_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "3761672050000000000000000/665074650676557", "value": 5656014773.940615 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "156749128315008718694600000000000000000/8072839971906988857081747849", "value": 19416850682.100292 } }, "ratio": { "exact_fraction": "3134982566300174373892/913202042975285359437", "value": 3.4329561463596274 }, "required_density_cm3": { "211": [ { "exact_fraction": "235104503125000000000000/4655522554735899", "value": 50500131.91018406 }, { "exact_fraction": "470209006250000000000000/7315821157442127", "value": 64272895.15841608 } ], "335": [ { "exact_fraction": "156749128315008718694600000000000000000/2316905071937305801982461632663", "value": 67654531.99338081 }, { "exact_fraction": "156749128315008718694600000000000000000/2123156912611538069412499684287", "value": 73828329.58973496 } ] }, "joint_EUV_density_cm3": null, "joint_EUV_radio_density_cm3": null, "predicted_times_s": { "stated_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "1880836025000000000/31258508581798179", "value": 60.17036993553846 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "78374564157504359347300000000000/379423478679628476282842148903", "value": 206.56224129893928 } }, "arithmetic_product_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "4702090062500000000/77813734129157169", "value": 60.42750826859631 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "195936410393760898368250000000000/944522276713117696278564498333", "value": 207.4449859198749 } }, "upstream_reference_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "188083602500000000/1995223952029671", "value": 94.26691289901025 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "7837456415750435934730000000000/24218519915720966571245243547", "value": 323.61417803500484 } } }, "printed_times_s": { "211": 94, "335": 323 }, "density_implied_by_printed_times_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "1880836025000000000000000/31258508581798179", "value": 60170369.935538456 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "156749128315008718694600000000000000000/2607527310925957400837404555227", "value": 60114088.79907211 } } }, { "temperature_MK": "2.8", "coefficients_s_per_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "177582081250000000000000/35786727973431", "value": 4962232964.74161 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "3336939446422471060168750000000000000/200520518181130935669652857", "value": 16641386510.921547 } }, "ratio": { "exact_fraction": "533910311427595369627/159204724068076346051", "value": 3.3536084720657784 }, "required_density_cm3": { "211": [ { "exact_fraction": "1585554296875000000000/35786727973431", "value": 44305651.470907226 }, { "exact_fraction": "22197760156250000000000/393654007707741", "value": 56389010.962972835 } ], "335": [ { "exact_fraction": "3336939446422471060168750000000000000/57549388717984578537190369959", "value": 57983925.125162184 }, { "exact_fraction": "3336939446422471060168750000000000000/52736896281637436081118701391", "value": 63275233.881830975 } ] }, "joint_EUV_density_cm3": null, "joint_EUV_radio_density_cm3": null, "predicted_times_s": { "stated_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "88791040625000000/1681976214751257", "value": 52.78971239086819 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "1668469723211235530084375000000/9424464354513153976473684279", "value": 177.03602671193136 } }, "arithmetic_product_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "221977601562500000/4187047172891427", "value": 53.015309452367624 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "4171174308028088825210937500000/23460900627192319473349384269", "value": 177.792590928649 } }, "upstream_reference_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "8879104062500000/107360183920293", "value": 82.70388274569349 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "166846972321123553008437500000/601561554543392807008958571", "value": 277.35644184869244 } } }, "printed_times_s": { "211": 83, "335": 277 }, "density_implied_by_printed_times_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "177582081250000000000000/2970298421794773", "value": 59785939.33423626 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "3336939446422471060168750000000000000/55544183536173269180493841389", "value": 60077207.6206554 } } }, { "temperature_MK": "3.0", "coefficients_s_per_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "1901714120000000000000000/429673536102213", "value": 4425951240.216969 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "34911649365992673795902500000000000000/2400138512292598840512236331", "value": 14545681087.649088 } }, "ratio": { "exact_fraction": "13964659746397069518361/4249158410069574976176", "value": 3.2864530805215177 }, "required_density_cm3": { "211": [ { "exact_fraction": "118857132500000000000000/3007714752715491", "value": 39517421.7876515 }, { "exact_fraction": "237714265000000000000000/4726408897124343", "value": 50294900.45701101 } ], "335": [ { "exact_fraction": "121643377581856006257500000000000000/2400138512292598840512236331", "value": 50681815.63640797 }, { "exact_fraction": "34911649365992673795902500000000000000/631236428732953495054718155053", "value": 55306772.19638436 } ] }, "joint_EUV_density_cm3": null, "joint_EUV_radio_density_cm3": null, "predicted_times_s": { "stated_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "950857060000000000/20194656196804011", "value": 47.084587661882644 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "17455824682996336897951250000000/112806510077752145504075107557", "value": 154.74128816647965 } }, "arithmetic_product_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "2377142650000000000/50271803723958921", "value": 47.285803848471886 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "43639561707490842244878125000000/280816205938234064339931650727", "value": 155.40257572274666 } }, "upstream_reference_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "95085706000000000/1289020608306639", "value": 73.76585400361614 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "1745582468299633689795125000000/7200415536877796521536708993", "value": 242.42801812748482 } } }, "printed_times_s": { "211": 74, "335": 242 }, "density_implied_by_printed_times_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "950857060000000000000000/15897920835781881", "value": 59810151.8948239 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "17455824682996336897951250000000000000/290416759987404459701980596051", "value": 60106120.19689706 } } }, { "temperature_MK": "3.2", "coefficients_s_per_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "2094386120000000000000000/523395693254133", "value": 4001534875.0358896 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "54612368207339823298141250000000000000/4226624268567543525337663239", "value": 12921036916.73749 } }, "ratio": { "exact_fraction": "43689894565871858638513/13530387531476867500768", "value": 3.229020193563002 }, "required_density_cm3": { "211": [ { "exact_fraction": "130899132500000000000000/3663769852778931", "value": 35727989.955677584 }, { "exact_fraction": "261798265000000000000000/5757352625795463", "value": 45471987.21631693 } ], "335": [ { "exact_fraction": "1332008980666824958491250000000000000/29586369879972804677363642673", "value": 45021034.5530923 }, { "exact_fraction": "54612368207339823298141250000000000000/1111602182633263947163805431857", "value": 49129417.93436308 } ] }, "joint_EUV_density_cm3": [ { "exact_fraction": "1332008980666824958491250000000000000/29586369879972804677363642673", "value": 45021034.5530923 }, { "exact_fraction": "261798265000000000000000/5757352625795463", "value": 45471987.21631693 } ], "joint_EUV_radio_density_cm3": null, "predicted_times_s": { "stated_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "1047193060000000000/24599597582944251", "value": 42.569519947190315 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "27306184103669911649070625000000/198651340622674545690870172233", "value": 137.45783953976053 } }, "arithmetic_product_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "2617982650000000000/61237296110733561", "value": 42.75144097260566 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "68265460259174779122676562500000/494515039422402592464506598963", "value": 138.04526620446038 } }, "upstream_reference_density_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "104719306000000000/1570187079762399", "value": 66.69224791726484 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "2730618410366991164907062500000/12679872805702630576012989717", "value": 215.35061527895817 } } }, "printed_times_s": { "211": 66, "335": 215 }, "density_implied_by_printed_times_cm3": { "211": { "exact_fraction": "1047193060000000000000000/17272057877386389", "value": 60629316.28842257 }, "335": { "exact_fraction": "10922473641467964659628250000000000000/181744843548404371589519519277", "value": 60097846.12436042 } } } ], "limits": [ "Only five printed temperatures; no interpolation or exclusion at untested temperatures.", "Printed atomic rates treated as fixed; no atomic-rate error estimates.", "Common constant density/temperature and sequential ionization times assumed.", "Observed band-ratio rise times need not equal ionization transit times.", "Hard bounds are a conditional interpretation of quoted errors, not confidence intervals.", "Same EUV/radio plasma parcel, radio harmonic and lane interpretation remain assumptions.", "No full non-equilibrium emission calculation, fit, raw-data acquisition or novelty claim.", "Version-specific arithmetic: arXiv v1; final publisher PDF not verified." ], "verification": [ { "name": "radio joint identity 127/150", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 127/165", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 127/180", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 132/150", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 132/165", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 132/180", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 137/150", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 137/165", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "radio joint identity 137/180", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.4 MK: independent decimal and exact rational coefficients", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.4 MK: ratio criterion equals shared-density intersection", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.4 MK: density cancels from time ratio", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.4 MK: printed integer times agree within 1 second at 6e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.4 MK: printed times are not reproduced at stated 9.4e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.4 MK: no shared density also in the radio range", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.6 MK: independent decimal and exact rational coefficients", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.6 MK: ratio criterion equals shared-density intersection", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.6 MK: density cancels from time ratio", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.6 MK: printed integer times agree within 1 second at 6e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.6 MK: printed times are not reproduced at stated 9.4e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.6 MK: no shared density also in the radio range", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.8 MK: independent decimal and exact rational coefficients", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.8 MK: ratio criterion equals shared-density intersection", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.8 MK: density cancels from time ratio", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.8 MK: printed integer times agree within 1 second at 6e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.8 MK: printed times are not reproduced at stated 9.4e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "2.8 MK: no shared density also in the radio range", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.0 MK: independent decimal and exact rational coefficients", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.0 MK: ratio criterion equals shared-density intersection", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.0 MK: density cancels from time ratio", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.0 MK: printed integer times agree within 1 second at 6e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.0 MK: printed times are not reproduced at stated 9.4e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.0 MK: no shared density also in the radio range", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: independent decimal and exact rational coefficients", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: ratio criterion equals shared-density intersection", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: density cancels from time ratio", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: printed integer times agree within 1 second at 6e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: printed times are not reproduced at stated 9.4e7", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: no shared density also in the radio range", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "3.2 MK: shared-density witness reproduces both bounded delays", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "exactly one of the five table rows admits a common EUV density", "status": "PASS" }, { "name": "no single density meets both EUV delays and harmonic radio at any tested row", "status": "PASS" } ] }